Tuesday, April 23, 2019

If you didn’t watch the Detroit Lions-Chicago Bears game, you didn’t miss much…. except perhaps the worst call of the NFL Season, if not history.

Okay, maybe that’s a bit exaggerated. But it’s definitely a highly questionable call that will be talked about for months and months. Especially if the Lions go on to have another crappy season with only a win a two.

Because the thing is, in my mind, and in a lot of minds (and not just Detroit fans), the Lions won that opening game. Which would put them in first place for the first time since 2007. Granted they would be tied for first with like 16 other teams but whatever. And they would have won the game in the final seconds of a game with a backup, relatively unknown QB at the helm–who managed to move the ball all the way down the field and get the ball in the endzone in less than a minute.

But in the official books and records, they did not win the game.

Even though the receiver Calvin Johnson did catch the ball in the endzone, with two hands, with full possession of the ball, and with the ball not slipping out when his entire body hit the grass.

But as he got up, CJ left the ball on the ground.

See the video of Calvin Johnson’s non-touchdown for yourself and you decide!

So it wasn’t a touchdown. It was ruled incomplete because he didn’t complete the full “process of the pass,” according to the announcers on NFL Red Zone anyway.

So what exactly is this mystical “process of the pass” that so few of us have ever heard of that just magically appeared at the end of this game? Or as Chris Chase said on Yahoo Sports, “When is a catch not a catch? When it happens in the NFL, apparently.”

Even Senior Correspondent Erik Sweetland, who is one of the biggest football fanatics I know, had only ever heard this call (or rule or whatever the NFL is coining this term) once. When the same situation happened to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers last year again the Miami Dolphins on November 13, 2009. And the Bucs lost that game as well.

I was told you can find this football rule in: Rule 8, Section 1, Article 3.


Rule 8, Section 1, Article 3, Item 1 of the NFL Rule Book (page 51) states that “if a player goes to the ground in the act of catching a pass (with or without contact with an opponent), he must maintain control of the ball after he touches the ground, whether in the field of play or the end zone. If he loses control of the ball, and the ball touches the ground before he regains control, the pass is incomplete. If he regains control prior to the ball touching the ground, the pass is complete.” Blogs NFl.Com

That doesn’t say, “said player must get up with the ball to maintain the process of the pass.”

A forward pass is complete when a receiver clearly possesses the pass and touches the ground with both feet inbounds while in possession of the ball. If a receiver would have landed inbounds with both feet but is carried or pushed out of bounds while maintaining possession of the ball, pass is complete at the out-of-bounds spot. –Rules Digest NFL.Com

Neither does that.

I Googled (and even Binged) this rule for over 30 minutes with every search term I could think of: “process of the pass, pass completion rules, NFL rules, Possession of the ball, touchdown completion rules, what makes a pass complete….etc.”

And nothing. Never saw any rules about a player having to stand up with the ball to make the pass complete in a touchdown situation. We know it must exist since it was called once before in that Tampa Bay game and it’s not like the league overturned the call after the game. But maybe they need to do a 2010 Edition of the Most Boring and Ridiculous Book of Crap NFL Rulebook that clearly outlines what they would like to see the players do in the end zone.

Because right now it kinda seems like the NFL would have rather Calvin Johnson, get up with the ball in hand and do an dance in the end zone, spiking the ball into the fans and get called for excessive celebration than just calming get up and leave the ball on the ground…..

How I love stupid NFL rules. Apparently Chris Chase does too. I leave you with the quote of the week:
“The runner did not complete the catch in the process of the catch?” Leave it to the NFL to make the simple concept of catching a ball as convoluted as Senate procedure for filibustering.

Why do there have to be so many conditions to a catch? Toddlers know when a ball is caught and when it isn’t. Aside from getting two feet in, what more does the NFL want people to do? Should Calvin Johnson have brought the ball with him to the sideline? Should he hold it for the flight home? Take it to dinner? When does the process of a catch end?”  Read more from Chris Chase at Sports.Yahoo.com

Check out the Stiletto Sports Guide to football rules and penalties for more stupid football technicalities! Or follow me on twitter, I talk about dumb football rules all the time!

About the author: Jennifer Taglione is the owner of this fabulous website Stiletto Sports. Despite writing well over 500 posts, she still maintains that she is not a sports writer! She is however a huge fan of Kurt Warner, Larry Fitzgerald, Mark Sanchez, the Celtics, and totally kicks butt on March Madness brackets! Connect with her by following her on Twitter @StilettoSportsJ and subscribing to her weekly newsletter. For more info check out the About the Editor page!

Now Available!

Comments & Feedback

Leave us some love!

You must be logged in to post a comment.

2 Responses

  1. Sally Said,

    Thanks for breaking this down so well! I didn’t get the Chicago game in VA, and I was trying to figure out what my FB friends were all talking about!

    Posted on September 12th, 2010 at 5:21 pm

  2. Stiletto Jen Said,

    I’m glad it helped! We were totally perplexed and shocked here–and we were watching it live!

    Posted on September 12th, 2010 at 6:53 pm

| HOME | Advertise | Contact | Join the Staff |Newsletter |
Shopping: Fierce & Fabulous Boutique | Shop! Stiletto Sports |

Stiletto Sports
Football Party Fashion!
scroll to see more great looks!

RSS FeedTwitter @stilettosportsJFacebook Fan PageShop Stiletto Sports

Signing Andrew Bogut Was A Win-Win Situation For The Los Angeles Lakers

The Los Angeles Lakers’ signing of Andrew Bogut drew plenty of reactions from both sides of the fence but his veteran status makes him an asset on the court and the bench.

How to Get Started with Roller Skating

Roller skating is both a fun leisure activity to get into and a challenging sport – and exercise – to keep your body healthy. It is making a comeback and growing in popularity in recent years, especially with more skating rinks now catering to skating fans across the country. Roller skating is also an easy sport to […]

Reasons why baseball has bigger money power than football

Baseball attracts millions of spectators, and it makes the largest amounts of money throughout the world. It is the main hero of sports pages of American newspapers, one of the main characters of books and movies. The famous baseball player of the 1940s Joe DiMaggio was no less popular than his starry wife Marilyn Monroe was. Baseball is a […]

The Top 5 Best Dressed (And Best Looking) NBA Rookies

Stiletto Sports is proud to bring you the Best Dressed 2016-17 NBA Rookies!